BERNARD NOVELL MUSIC BOXES
  • Welcome
    • About
    • History
  • The Collection
    • Cartels >
      • 12/195 Lecoultre Freres Cartel
      • 12/129 NF Fat Cylinder
      • 8/130 Cuendet
      • 8/122 Ducommun-Girod
      • 8/97 Nicole Freres
      • 8/78 Langdorff & Fils
      • 8/77 Bremond Drum & Bells
      • 8/77 Paillard Vaucher HE
      • 6/107 Nicole Freres
      • 6/104 Nicol Freres
      • 6/103 Unknown
      • 4/78 Nicole Freres??
      • 4/57 Unknown
      • 4/50 George Baker
      • 3/99 Cartel
      • 2/82 Rzebitschek
    • Petites Musique's >
      • 6/51 Petites Musique
      • 6/50 Petites Musique RD
      • 6/50 Paillard PM
      • 6/42 Bremond
      • 4/82 Fortisimo
      • 4/77 Mandoline Zither
      • 4/52 American PM
      • 3/70 Burr Walnut PM
    • Tabatiéres >
      • 12/37 Ullmann
      • 4/61 Hamburg Tabatiere
      • 3/57 Burr Walnut
      • 3 Air Composition Tabatiere
      • 2/70 Brass / Oak Tabatiére
      • 2/69 Ebony
      • 2/69 Ducummun Girod
      • 2/59 Leather Cased Tabatiere
      • 2/55 Tortoiseshell
      • 2/52 US Ebony
    • Classic
    • Manivelles >
      • Multiphone Manivelle
    • Disc Players >
      • Symphonion Brevete
    • Ceramic
    • Jewellery Boxes
    • Paperweights
    • Novelties
    • Non Musical Boxes
    • Other Items >
      • Wooden Games
      • Geneva Wheel
  • The Workshop
    • In the Workshop >
      • Bird Barrel Organ
      • 12/129 NF Fat Cylinder RD
      • 10/69 Bremond
      • 6/72 Lecoultre Freres
      • 4/82 Chevob RD
      • 4/78 Nicole Freres RD
      • 4/75 Paillard Mandolin RD
      • 4/62 River Scene Tab RD
      • 4/60 Maple Diamond
      • 2/51 Photo Album Tabatiere RD
    • Coming Soon >
      • 8/97 Nicole Freres RD
      • 8/77 Bremond Drum & Bells RD
    • How to restore a Music Box >
      • Mechanism Restoration
      • Case Restoration
      • Small mechanism restoration
  • Private Projects
    • 12/195 Lecoultre Freres RD
    • 12/72 Unknown RD
    • 8/130 Cuendet RD
    • 8/122 Ducummun Girod RD
    • 8/88 Paillard, Vaucher et Fils
    • 8/79 L'Epee RD
    • 8/78 Langdorff et Fills RD
    • 6/107 Nicole Freres RD
    • 6/104 Nicol Freres RD
    • 6/103 Unknown RD
    • 6/57 Cartel RD
    • 6/41 PVF Bells RD
    • 6/41 Ami Rivenc Cartel RD
    • 4/57 Unknown RD
    • 4/50 George Baker RD
    • 3/99 Opera Cartel RD
    • 3/36 Silver Birch Tabatiére
    • 3/36 Small Oak Tabatiére
    • 3/36 Burl Walnut Tabatiére
    • 2/82 Rzebitschek RD
    • 2/70 Piano Nécessaire
    • 2/69 Ducummun Girod RD
    • 2/58 Carved Paillard
    • 2/50 Cuendet
    • 2/32 Painted Music Box
    • 2/18 Personalised Mahogany Box
    • 1/37 Personalised Mahogany Box
    • 1/37 Personalised Oak Box
    • 1/18 Carousel
    • Cigarette Box Conversions
    • Do-terra Box
    • Japanese Box
  • Commissions
    • Commissions & Restorations >
      • 1/18 Chalet
      • Polyfon case
      • 12/62 PVF Cartel RD
      • 2/56 JGM RD
      • 6/66 Perrelet RD
      • Watson
      • Repair Shop >
        • Bagatelle
        • Chequered Table
        • High Chair
        • Jewellery Box
        • Mills
    • Completed Commissions >
      • 12/72 Nicole Freres
      • 12/62 Paillard Vaucher
      • 8/77 Unattributed
      • 6/57 Cartel
      • 4/113 Henriot
      • 4/50 Reuge in Tunbridge Ware Music Box
      • 2/56 Tabatiere SG
      • 2/22 Trinket Box
      • 1/29 Cigarette Box
      • 1/18 Premilex
      • 1/18 Secol Carousel
      • 1/18 Tunbridge Ballerina Box
      • 1/18 White Christmas
      • Pair of small 1/18 Boxes
      • Queen Victoria Album
      • Seasons Photo Album
      • Necklace Box
      • Sewing Boxes x 2
      • Travel Box - Boyd
      • Two small boxes
      • Victorian Sewing Box
      • Victorian Writing Slope 2
      • Victorian Writing Slope
      • Walnut Writing Slope
  • Shop
    • For Sale >
      • 8/88 Pallard, Vaucher et Fils
      • 8/79 L'Epee Cartel
      • 8/38 Mermod Freres
      • 8/25 Unknown in Oak Box
      • 6/58 Ami Rivenc
    • Stock
    • Sold >
      • 12/72 Unknown
      • 6/41 PVF Bells in sight
      • 6/41 Ami Rivenc
      • 2/55 Photo Album
      • 2/22 Photo Album Movement
      • 1/18 Ex Mallorca box
      • 1/18 Balerina Jewellery Box
      • 1/18 Georgian Box
      • Japanese Butterfly Box
      • Barrel Organ Manivelle Kit
  • Links
    • Glossary of Terms
Picture

6/57 Cartel

This cartel belongs to a friend who entrusted me to restore it to its former glory as it was when it was bought by her grandfather.
It has been stored for some time but the mechanism is in very good order except it needs a good clean and polish and there are four broken comb tips and some missing dampers.
The box had a few minor marquetry issues.
The tune sheet that would help to identify the maker is, unfortunately, missing. However, the second tune I have identified as The Toreador’s Song (1875).
Others have recently been identified as La Jolie Persane by Lecocq (1879) and The Waltz of Madame Favart by Offenbach (1878)
Scroll down for more about the tunes. Can you help identify the other three?
It would be a year to eighteen months after a popular tune was released for it to be found on a music box. We can therefore assume that this box dates to about 1880/81 which ties into its original owner's marriage date.
Main mechanism
Spring motor. Note broken teeth on comb
Missing box banding
Missing leaf inlay
Missing box banding
Broken teeth & bent pins

17th May 2021
The mechanism
Removed from box and completely dismantled.
Comb removed and movement mounted on blocks
Underside of Comb
Close up of teeth and dampers
Comb fixing screws
Stop arm and screw
Tune change lever & screw
Cylinder arbour bearing bracket & screws
Vane & Governor bracket, jewel & screws
Governor assembly
Governor assembly from below
Governor assembly from above
Arbour bearing & screws
Spring motor assembly
Geneva stop assembly
Bedplate
Winding lever assembly
Arbour bearing, pawl & ratchet
Geneva stop - female - & screw
Arbour bearing, pawl, ratchet, spring & screws
Winding lever, pawl, busk, spring & screws
Cylinder - partially cleaned
Comb lead weights showing broken teeth
Comb base end, showing broken teeth
Cylinder cleaned awaiting polish
Cylinder cleaned awaiting polish
The owner decided that they would like to have the comb repaired by a professional repairer who replaced the damaged fingers, any missing dampers, reunite the comb with the mechanism and test / adjust it to perfection.

Mechanism in pieces and being inspected for damage.
​Note: I decided not to remove the spring as the housing etc. is in really good condition and all works.
Picture

After the inspection nothing was found to be damaged or missing, in fact it appears to have all original parts including return springs (which is rare).
The bedplate was painted gold and all parts went through a four part cleaning & polishing process.
From now on cotton gloves must be used to handle the brass to avoid oils from the skin causing tarnish.
​The governor assembly and spring motor & winder were reassembled before setting the mechanism back onto the bedplate.

Cleaning and polishing process
1. All the smaller components were immersed in an ultrasonic water bath with a degreaser added, then given several cycles to loosen the dirt and grease. This was rinsed with warm water and an old toothbrush used to aid the process.
2. The same components were immersed overnight in a 7:1 solution for water and Horolene to remove the majority of tarnish.
3. The brass components were scrubbed, using a fine soft toothbrush, using Johnson's Brass Polish. then rinsed and thoroughly dried. The cylinder was also cleaned with the same polish. The holes in the end caps were carefully sealed using strong tape to ensure that no polish entered the inside of the cylinder.
Extreme care must be taken with these two processes as the solutions contain ammonia and other chemicals that can cause health issues, so wear all necessary PPE
4. The brass was polished using Autosol (car chrome cleaner) and buffed to a shine using a fine horse hair brush.
​5. The steel components were thoroughly cleaned using various wire brushes and polished using 0000 grade wire wool or fine carborundum paper.
​6. The bedplate was degreased using WD40 degreaser and thens scrubbed with a wire brush before being painted with two coats of antique gold acrylic paint and left to dry for several days.

Painted bedplate
Polished cylinder
Governor (outer view)
Governor (inner view)
Spring motor (outer view)
Spring motor (inner view)
Mechanism reassembled
Governor (without stop arm)
Spring motor & winder
Spring motor
Governor rotating
The comb needed four new tips and some dampers. This work was undertaken by The Music Box Restorer who also reunited the comb with the movement and tested it. See below. Can you see the joins?

The Box
There was not too much serious damage to the box, but the marquetry and boxwood stringing on the top was missing some pieces and the surface looked like it has been varnished. Repairs to the missing inlays was relatively simple and the top was then rubbed down to reveal some lovely grain. The box itself was sound but the outer finish needed tlc. I decided to strip it and re-finish with woodstain and then French polish the whole box. While doing this I made the single boxwood string on the front panel stand out as this had been 'lost'.
String about to be glued in place
Small string glued and taped
Large string trimmed
Small string trimmed
Sanded flush
Sanded flush
Missing leaf ready to glue
All inlay filled and sanded
Front stripped to reveal stringing

Polishing the box, starting with black French polish for the interior, inside the lid, and edges of the lid.
Second pass with roughness taken off using 0000 grade wire wool for a super smooth finish. Two or three more coats to go.
The last six images show the final polish immediately after application.

The final result after several months has been well worth the wait and effort. Returned to owner 15th November 2021
Toreador's Song by Bizet from Carmen
Unknown tune. Do you recognise it or any of the others?
​Contact me if you can help
A quirk of the system here.
​Download really means, open window. The problem is it overwrites the current one, so just navigate back to it when you've listened.

Tune 1

Tune 2 - The Toreador's Song by Bizet from the Opera Carmen

Tune 3

Tune 4 - La Jolie Persane by Lecocq 1879

Tune 5 - The Waltz of Madame Favart by Offenbach

Tune 6

Contact me
​Cookie Policy
Site last updated 14th December 2025​
Images are Copyright of Elvendon Images and may not be copied or used without express permission in writing.
  • Welcome
    • About
    • History
  • The Collection
    • Cartels >
      • 12/195 Lecoultre Freres Cartel
      • 12/129 NF Fat Cylinder
      • 8/130 Cuendet
      • 8/122 Ducommun-Girod
      • 8/97 Nicole Freres
      • 8/78 Langdorff & Fils
      • 8/77 Bremond Drum & Bells
      • 8/77 Paillard Vaucher HE
      • 6/107 Nicole Freres
      • 6/104 Nicol Freres
      • 6/103 Unknown
      • 4/78 Nicole Freres??
      • 4/57 Unknown
      • 4/50 George Baker
      • 3/99 Cartel
      • 2/82 Rzebitschek
    • Petites Musique's >
      • 6/51 Petites Musique
      • 6/50 Petites Musique RD
      • 6/50 Paillard PM
      • 6/42 Bremond
      • 4/82 Fortisimo
      • 4/77 Mandoline Zither
      • 4/52 American PM
      • 3/70 Burr Walnut PM
    • Tabatiéres >
      • 12/37 Ullmann
      • 4/61 Hamburg Tabatiere
      • 3/57 Burr Walnut
      • 3 Air Composition Tabatiere
      • 2/70 Brass / Oak Tabatiére
      • 2/69 Ebony
      • 2/69 Ducummun Girod
      • 2/59 Leather Cased Tabatiere
      • 2/55 Tortoiseshell
      • 2/52 US Ebony
    • Classic
    • Manivelles >
      • Multiphone Manivelle
    • Disc Players >
      • Symphonion Brevete
    • Ceramic
    • Jewellery Boxes
    • Paperweights
    • Novelties
    • Non Musical Boxes
    • Other Items >
      • Wooden Games
      • Geneva Wheel
  • The Workshop
    • In the Workshop >
      • Bird Barrel Organ
      • 12/129 NF Fat Cylinder RD
      • 10/69 Bremond
      • 6/72 Lecoultre Freres
      • 4/82 Chevob RD
      • 4/78 Nicole Freres RD
      • 4/75 Paillard Mandolin RD
      • 4/62 River Scene Tab RD
      • 4/60 Maple Diamond
      • 2/51 Photo Album Tabatiere RD
    • Coming Soon >
      • 8/97 Nicole Freres RD
      • 8/77 Bremond Drum & Bells RD
    • How to restore a Music Box >
      • Mechanism Restoration
      • Case Restoration
      • Small mechanism restoration
  • Private Projects
    • 12/195 Lecoultre Freres RD
    • 12/72 Unknown RD
    • 8/130 Cuendet RD
    • 8/122 Ducummun Girod RD
    • 8/88 Paillard, Vaucher et Fils
    • 8/79 L'Epee RD
    • 8/78 Langdorff et Fills RD
    • 6/107 Nicole Freres RD
    • 6/104 Nicol Freres RD
    • 6/103 Unknown RD
    • 6/57 Cartel RD
    • 6/41 PVF Bells RD
    • 6/41 Ami Rivenc Cartel RD
    • 4/57 Unknown RD
    • 4/50 George Baker RD
    • 3/99 Opera Cartel RD
    • 3/36 Silver Birch Tabatiére
    • 3/36 Small Oak Tabatiére
    • 3/36 Burl Walnut Tabatiére
    • 2/82 Rzebitschek RD
    • 2/70 Piano Nécessaire
    • 2/69 Ducummun Girod RD
    • 2/58 Carved Paillard
    • 2/50 Cuendet
    • 2/32 Painted Music Box
    • 2/18 Personalised Mahogany Box
    • 1/37 Personalised Mahogany Box
    • 1/37 Personalised Oak Box
    • 1/18 Carousel
    • Cigarette Box Conversions
    • Do-terra Box
    • Japanese Box
  • Commissions
    • Commissions & Restorations >
      • 1/18 Chalet
      • Polyfon case
      • 12/62 PVF Cartel RD
      • 2/56 JGM RD
      • 6/66 Perrelet RD
      • Watson
      • Repair Shop >
        • Bagatelle
        • Chequered Table
        • High Chair
        • Jewellery Box
        • Mills
    • Completed Commissions >
      • 12/72 Nicole Freres
      • 12/62 Paillard Vaucher
      • 8/77 Unattributed
      • 6/57 Cartel
      • 4/113 Henriot
      • 4/50 Reuge in Tunbridge Ware Music Box
      • 2/56 Tabatiere SG
      • 2/22 Trinket Box
      • 1/29 Cigarette Box
      • 1/18 Premilex
      • 1/18 Secol Carousel
      • 1/18 Tunbridge Ballerina Box
      • 1/18 White Christmas
      • Pair of small 1/18 Boxes
      • Queen Victoria Album
      • Seasons Photo Album
      • Necklace Box
      • Sewing Boxes x 2
      • Travel Box - Boyd
      • Two small boxes
      • Victorian Sewing Box
      • Victorian Writing Slope 2
      • Victorian Writing Slope
      • Walnut Writing Slope
  • Shop
    • For Sale >
      • 8/88 Pallard, Vaucher et Fils
      • 8/79 L'Epee Cartel
      • 8/38 Mermod Freres
      • 8/25 Unknown in Oak Box
      • 6/58 Ami Rivenc
    • Stock
    • Sold >
      • 12/72 Unknown
      • 6/41 PVF Bells in sight
      • 6/41 Ami Rivenc
      • 2/55 Photo Album
      • 2/22 Photo Album Movement
      • 1/18 Ex Mallorca box
      • 1/18 Balerina Jewellery Box
      • 1/18 Georgian Box
      • Japanese Butterfly Box
      • Barrel Organ Manivelle Kit
  • Links
    • Glossary of Terms